What is an Email Audit (& Why Do One)?
Many e-commerce businesses are hurting right now due to inflation and the general state of the economy. And every platform and marketing channel claims to give you the best returns on your marketing spend. So, how do you decide which efforts to prioritize?
» Uncover the truth about those “easy money” claims here: "Email is Easy Money” and Other Email Marketing Myths
While you've probably heard that email is still one of the best channels for ROI, it might not feel that way for your business. That’s where an email audit comes in—it’s a smart way to ensure your marketing spend is working at maximum efficiency. Whether you’re a pro at email marketing or just starting out, this post will break down what an email audit is and how it could benefit your business.
What is an Email Audit?
An email audit is like a checkup for your email marketing. It’s a way to look closely at how your emails are doing—like how many people are opening them, clicking on links, or making purchases after reading them. The audit helps you see what’s working well and where your greatest areas of opportunity are. By doing this, you can make sure that your emails are reaching your customers and encouraging them to take action, which means you’re getting the most out of your marketing efforts.
Review of Email Performance Metrics
One of the first things you want to look at is how your emails are performing based on key metrics like open rates, click rates, and sales conversions. While these numbers might be familiar, an audit takes a deeper dive into understanding what these metrics are really telling you. Are your emails engaging enough to prompt action? Are they driving the sales you need? This review ensures that your emails aren’t just being sent—they’re making an impact.
In-Depth Analysis
Many people may believe that keeping an eye on basic metrics is enough to gauge the success of their email marketing. While these numbers are important, they only tell part of the story. An email audit should also include in-depth analysis, going beyond surface-level metrics to gain an even deeper understanding.
Past Performance
Analyzing trends over the past year (or more) to understand how your emails are performing today compared to past sends.
Understanding past performance is crucial in an email audit. This involves looking back at how your emails have performed over the past year or more. For instance, did your holiday promotions drive the sales you expected last year? Or perhaps your spring campaign saw a dip in engagement. Analyzing trends over time makes it easier to spot patterns—like certain times of the year when your emails perform better or worse. This insight allows you to replicate successful strategies and adjust where needed.
A practical action item from this analysis could be adjusting your email content or timing based on what has worked well in the past. If you notice that emails sent on weekday mornings tend to have higher open rates, you might want to prioritize that timing for future campaigns. Similarly, if certain types of content consistently drive more sales, you can focus more on creating similar emails in the future.
Other Key Metrics
Going beyond basic open and click rates to evaluate sales conversions, bounces, unsubscribes, and overall list health.
While open and click rates are important, an email audit dives deeper into other key metrics that can significantly impact your success. For example, sales conversions tell you whether your emails are actually driving purchases, not just getting clicks. Bounces and unsubscribes give insights into your list’s health—are your emails reaching the right people, or are you losing subscribers over time?
Evaluating these metrics helps you understand the full picture. If you notice a high bounce rate, it might be time to clean up your list or adjust your email content to better meet your audience’s needs. Similarly, a high unsubscribe rate could signal that your emails aren’t resonating with your audience, prompting a review of your messaging strategy. Focusing on these deeper metrics allows you to make more informed decisions to improve your email marketing efforts.
Deliverability
Ensure your emails land in inboxes by analyzing bounce rates and spam complaints and focusing on sending them to your most engaged subscribers.
Deliverability is key to ensuring your emails actually reach your subscribers’ inboxes, rather than getting lost in spam folders. An email audit assesses this by looking at hard and soft bounce rates, as well as spam complaint rates. High bounce rates can indicate issues with your email list, like outdated or incorrect email addresses, while spam complaints can signal that your content might not be resonating with your audience.
One important factor in improving deliverability is focusing on increasing your open and click rates. A smaller, more engaged list is often more effective than sending to your entire list every time. Inboxes tend to prioritize emails that show high engagement, so by targeting those who have recently opened, clicked, made a purchase, or interacted with your site, you can boost your overall deliverability.
While it’s tempting to send every email to your entire list, being more targeted and segmented usually leads to better inbox placement and higher engagement. You can still keep your full list for special events and big promotions, but for regular emails, focusing on your most engaged subscribers will likely yield better results.
Email Content and Design
Assessing the effectiveness of email templates, design, and the content itself.
The look and feel of your emails play a big role in how they’re received. An audit reviews your email templates and design to ensure they’re not just visually appealing but also functional. For example, are your emails mobile-friendly? With more people checking emails on their phones, a design that looks great on desktop but is hard to read on mobile can hurt engagement.
The content itself is equally important. Are your subject lines clear and enticing? Does the body copy speak directly to your audience’s needs and encourage them to take action? By assessing both design and content, you can make sure your emails are not only opened but also lead to clicks and conversions.
Action items from this review might include simplifying your email layout, improving mobile responsiveness, or tweaking your messaging to better connect with your audience. Small changes in design and content can significantly impact your overall email performance.
Automations and Workflows
Checking how well your automated emails are performing and identify areas for improvement.
Automated emails, like welcome series or abandoned cart reminders, are powerful tools that work in the background to engage your customers. An audit checks how well these automations perform by looking at their effectiveness and timing. For instance, is your welcome series converting new subscribers into customers, or do you see a drop-off after the first email? Are your cart abandonment emails prompting people to complete their purchases, or are they being ignored?
By analyzing these workflows, you can identify areas for improvement, such as adjusting the timing of emails, personalizing content based on customer behavior, or adding steps to nurture leads more effectively. Minor tweaks in your automation strategy can lead to higher engagement and better results, ensuring that your automated emails are truly working for you.
Testing and Optimization
Ensuring all integrations, forms, and landing pages function correctly and are optimized for conversions.
Effective email marketing depends on the smooth operation of all your technical components, like integrations, forms, and landing pages. An audit involves testing these elements to ensure they’re working correctly and optimized for conversions. For example, are your signup forms capturing new subscribers without errors? Are the integrations between your email platform and your CRM running smoothly?
Optimization goes beyond functionality—it’s also about enhancing performance. This might involve tweaking landing page designs to make them more engaging or ensuring that your forms are easy to complete and submit. Regular testing and optimization help catch issues early and refine your setup to maximize conversions and improve user experience.
Why Conduct an Email Audit?
Understanding the value of an email audit can be a game-changer for your marketing strategy. It’s not just about checking the basics; it’s a comprehensive review that helps you get the most out of your email efforts.
1. Maximize Marketing Spend
Every marketing dollar counts, especially in these challenging economic times. An email audit ensures that your budget is used effectively by pinpointing what’s working and what needs adjustment. By fine-tuning your email strategy, you can achieve the highest return on your investment and make sure every dollar is well spent.
2. Identify Opportunities
Even if your email program is performing well, an audit can reveal areas for further improvement. It helps uncover opportunities to optimize your strategy, enhancing what’s already working and addressing any hidden issues. This continuous refinement can lead to even greater success.
3. Better Understand Subscriber Behavior
An audit provides valuable insights into how your subscribers interact with your emails. It helps you understand what content resonates most, what drives engagement, and why certain behaviors, like unsubscribes, occur. This deeper understanding allows you to tailor your emails more effectively to meet your audience’s needs.
4. Answer Specific Questions
If you’re facing particular challenges with your email marketing, an audit can be customized to address those issues. Whether you’re struggling with low engagement or wondering why your list isn’t growing, an email audit can provide targeted answers and actionable solutions.
Questions an Email Audit Can Answer
Next, we’ll take a closer look at some common email marketing questions and how an audit can uncover data-backed, actionable solutions.
Delivery
Are my emails landing in spam? What can I do if they are?
If emails are ending up in spam folders, it can hurt your engagement and overall effectiveness. An email audit can help you diagnose delivery issues and suggest ways to improve your inbox placement. For more detailed guidance on addressing this issue, check out our blog post, What To Do if Your Emails Go to Spam: A How-To Guide.
Churn
Why is my list shrinking, and what can I do to keep subscribers around longer?
If your subscriber list is getting smaller, it might feel like you’re losing touch with your audience. An audit can help identify why people are unsubscribing—maybe they’re not getting the content they signed up for, or your emails are coming too often. With these insights, you can make adjustments to keep subscribers engaged, like offering more personalized content or adjusting your send frequency.
Performance
I had high unsubscribe rates on my industry's biggest holiday. Why did that happen?
Seeing a lot of unsubscribes during a key holiday can be frustrating. It might be that your emails weren’t what people were expecting, or they felt overwhelmed by too many messages. An audit can dig into what happened and suggest changes, like tweaking your email content or pacing your sends better during busy times, to keep your audience happy and engaged.
Engagement
My open and click rates are going down, or are lower than I want. What can I do?
If your open and click rates are slipping, it could be that your content isn’t connecting with your audience anymore. Maybe your subject lines need a refresh, or your emails aren’t arriving when people are most likely to open them. An audit can help pinpoint these issues and suggest simple fixes, like trying out new subject lines or adjusting your send times to boost engagement.
Visibility
How can I stand out as the email channel becomes more saturated? Should I send texts, too?
In a crowded inbox, it’s easy to get lost in the shuffle. An audit can show you ways to make your emails stand out, like using eye-catching designs or more personalized content. And yes, adding SMS to your strategy is often a good move, especially for e-commerce brands. The audit can help you build an SMS list and figure out how to integrate it with your email marketing for better results.
Behavior
My subscribers are coming back to my emails months and even years later to shop. Why is that?
It’s a good sign if subscribers return to your emails after a long time—it means you’ve got something they value. An audit can help you understand what’s driving this behavior, like specific offers or content that really resonates. With this insight, you can create more of what works and keep your audience coming back for more.
Design
What should my emails look like? How long should they be?
If you’re wondering about the best way to design your emails, an audit can help you find what works. Maybe your emails are too long, or the design isn’t user-friendly enough. The audit can suggest improvements, like simplifying your layout or shortening your content, to make your emails more engaging and easier to read.
Timing
When should I send? How often—daily? Weekly? Monthly?
Finding the right time to send emails can be tricky. Reviewing past performance data can help you figure out the best timing by looking at when your audience is most active. Whether you should send daily, weekly, or monthly depends on your audience and content, and your findings can guide you to the schedule that works best.
Planning
We had to rush last holiday season. What should we be looking at in advance this year?
If last holiday season felt chaotic, planning ahead is key. An audit can help you prepare by identifying what worked and what didn’t in the past. With this information, you can create a more organized plan for this year, making sure you’re ready well in advance with content, designs, and schedules that align with your goals.
How an Email Audit Can Transform Your Strategy
We know that simply sending emails isn’t enough. To truly succeed, you need to ensure that every part of your email marketing strategy is working to its full potential. Here are some of the most powerful ways a comprehensive email audit can transform your strategy.
1. Problem-Solving
An email audit is more than just a checkup; it's a diagnostic tool that helps identify and correct issues that may be hindering your email marketing.
2. Enhancing Success
Even if your emails perform well, there’s always room for improvement. An audit provides new ideas and strategies to refine and enhance what's already working, ensuring you stay ahead of the curve.
3. Making Marketing Spend Go Further
You’re already spending time, money, and energy on emails. Get more back for it with efforts that impact big-picture performance!
4. Long-Term Benefits
Regular email audits aren’t just a one-time fix. They offer long-term strategic value by fostering continuous improvement, helping you stay ahead of trends, and keeping your campaigns competitive in an ever-changing market.
Now that you understand how an email audit can transform your strategy, it's clear why this step is essential for any serious e-commerce business. By reviewing and optimizing your email efforts, you're setting your business up for greater engagement, higher conversions, and long-term growth.
Ready to take the next step?
We offer customized, in-depth email audits that will answer your questions and provide personalized recommendations tailored to your business needs.
EXPLORE THE FULL MINI-SERIES:
1. What is an owned channel?
Learn the definition, examples, plus the 3 other channel types (paid, earned, converged).
2. How do I know what emails to send?
How to create email content that matters to your subscribers, how often to send it, and how to stay on schedule.
3. Is it worth it to pay for a unique design for every email?
You might be surprised to hear that our answer is "Not always," even as people who get paid to design emails! Find out why.
📍 YOU ARE HERE: 
4. What is an email audit & does our brand need one?
Not every brand needs an email audit, but it's a critical tool for those who want to identify growth opportunities.
5. Is Marketing SMS right for my brand?
The SMS channel is less saturated, but requires a bit more effort to set up and grow your list.
Never miss out on new posts to help you improve your email and SMS marketing 
[…] 4. What is an email audit & does our brand need one? Not every brand needs an email audit, but it's a critical tool for those who want to identify growth opportunities. […]